Wednesday, May 30, 2007

Veganism - Diet that kills?

There have been a spate of reports lately of Vegan parents in Atlanta, GA being charged with murder for the death of their new born who they had tried raising as Vegan. This was very disturbing when I first read this. The media has been sensationalizing the case with headlines like 'Death by Veganism' (in recent NYTimes Op-ed) and seem to be pointing the finger at the Vegan movement as a whole.

Was it really Vegan diet that caused the baby's death, or were there other factors. Even if it was Vegan diet that really caused the death, is it right to charge the parents of murder.

Reading through the articles on this story on the web, it does not appear that the baby died simply because of Vegan diet. There seems to be a larger case of neglect. The baby was born in a bathtub, the baby was never taken to a hospital by its parents for the fear of the hospital being 'infested with germs'. And most importantly, the baby seems to have been under-fed. Insufficient diet seems to be the problem here rather than Vegan diet. Its not a case of 'Vegan' parents causing their baby's death, instead 'stupid' parents leading to their baby's demise.

Now this brings to the other concern I have with the story - that of the harsh verdict. Since when is stupidity a capital crime. The first-time parents in this case clearly were negligent & irresponsible but do they deserve to spend the rest of the life in prison for ignorance? They clearly were not intending to cause harm to their child and were doing what they felt was best for the kid.

One can extend this verdict to sentence low-income parents whose children may die of malnourishment. This logic if applied in many of the third world nations will see their prisons swell with 'poor' parents. A not so extreme extrapoloation of this verdict would be in the case of children who grow up as religious fanatics. Will parents be charged for raising their children with strict religious dogma if the child grows up to be an extremist and hurts others!! One can make a case that the parents should have known better.

The Atlanta verdict is clearly a flawed one and hope it is overturned soon.

For another post ...
There seem to be articles online, not very objective going by the source, indicating that Vegan diet is fine for babies of all ages. But is it really the case. For that matter, is it even good for adults. Veganism is a relatively new way of life and we don't have enough information to judge long-term impacts of such a diet.

4 comments:

Archana Raghuram said...

Hi Arun
I have tagged you for “The 8 Random Facts About Me” meme. Request you to respond. Refer to my post for the rules (http://archanaraghuram.wordpress.com/2007/06/25/8-random-facts-about-me-meme/)

Mahesh said...

Hi Arun

This verdict is heights of stupidity, I'd say. If a vegan diet can kill a baby, there wouldn't have been a sect called 'brahmans' in India, who once used to be strict vegetarians. Even now there are. This one-off case is solely due to neglect, lack of breast feed, unwanted fears. But in a country like US, where anything can be a headline, we dont have to worry about it :-)

Arun Sankaranarayanan said...

Mahesh, I agree that the verdict is bizarre. I was also a little perturbed by the fact that even reputed newspapers like NYTimes were pointing fingers without doing their homework (although the damning article was published in an Op-ed piece not in an editorial).

Anonymous said...

Arun - Have the parents been charged with murder or reckless endangerment of human life? I believe they are guilty of the latter. There is a pattern of systematic neglect.

I disagree with Mahesh. Brahmins are not vegans. They are lacto (& sometimes also lacto-ovo) vegetarians.